You say it in every all-hands. My door is always open. You mean it. You’d welcome someone walking in with a hard truth, a bad piece of feedback, a concern about something you’re doing wrong.
And almost nobody comes.
The mistake is thinking that’s about access. It isn’t. Nobody is checking whether your door is open. They’re checking what happened the last time someone walked through it, or one like it, and what it cost them.
Maybe nothing dramatic happened. You didn’t retaliate, didn’t get visibly angry. You just got a little quieter. A little more clipped in the next interaction. You nodded, said “thanks for flagging that,” and then nothing changed. That’s enough. Everyone present, and everyone who heard about it afterward, filed away the same lesson: this door opens, but nothing comes of it.
I work with a CEO who was baffled by this. He’d built what he thought was an unusually open culture. He held office hours. He said the right things about wanting to hear bad news early. And yet every serious problem in the company kept arriving late, already turned into a crisis, without ever reaching him directly.
The answer wasn’t complicated. Six months earlier, someone had brought him a real concern, respectfully, directly, exactly the way he said he wanted it. His response, however understandable in the moment, had been visibly defensive. A slightly sharper tone. A slightly too-fast explanation for why the concern didn’t apply. But that single interaction did more to set the culture than a hundred mentions of his open door.
Nobody declares approachability. The same principle Brené Brown describes with marble jars applies here: it accumulates, one tested moment at a time, and everyone already knows where you stand, even if nobody says so out loud.
This is why approachability gets treated as a personality trait when it’s actually a track record. Warm, doesn’t yell, none of that determines whether people bring you the truth. What determines it is the handful of times someone actually tested you, and what they saw happen next. You don’t earn approachability by having the door. You earn it, or lose it, by what happens when someone walks through it.
Here’s a way to check where you stand, and it’s more reliable than asking your team directly, since they’ll tell you what’s safe to say about your door, not what they believe about it. Think back to the last hard piece of feedback you received, not a mild suggestion, an actual hard truth about your leadership or a decision you made. When was that, who was it from, and what happened to them afterward, in ways they could observe even if you never intended anything by it.
If you can’t answer that quickly, that’s the answer. Either nobody has tested you in a long time, or you’ve never paid attention to what happened when they did.
You can’t fix a track record by telling people more about the door. You fix it the next time someone brings you something hard, by managing your own reaction as carefully as you’d manage a client relationship, because that’s exactly what it is: taking in what they said, visibly enough that the next person who tests it gets a better answer than the last one did.






